So because a band is popular it discredits their music ? And then this thread is"Best albums you've ever listened to" so if GNR is one of the best albums they have listened to wtf has it got to do with what genre it is. They never said it was the best album ever so your potato analogy is completely wrong. I'm not a huge fan of GNR but they have some catchy songs. I really liked the Underoath albums.